Blog/⚽ Premier League

Sunderland Are the Unluckiest Team in the Premier League. The Numbers Are Brutal.

A 4.8-point gap between expected and actual points makes Sunderland the most cursed side in England.

Sunderland
Sunderland
Premier League · season
Record
2W 2D 6L
Points
8
Expected
12.8
Season xG underperformance-0.9 goals
Expected: 8.9 Actual: 8
Premier League · 10 games · Updated daily

Bottom line: Sunderland have lost 4.8 points to variance alone this season, making them the single unluckiest team in the Premier League.

Through November 21, 2026, Sunderland's record reads 2W-2D-6L. Eight points from ten matches. That is a relegation trajectory by any honest accounting. But the expected-points model, built on shot quality and match context per FBref data, says they should be sitting on 12.8 points. The 4.8-point deficit between what the underlying numbers predicted and what actually happened is the largest negative gap in the division. By the CURSD Luck Index, which synthesizes finishing variance, defensive variance, schedule difficulty, and injury burden into a single composite score, Sunderland register at -37, the most cursed mark in the league.

They are also, let's be clear, not a good team. The curse and the crisis coexist.

The xPoints Gap: 4.8 Points Left on the Pitch

The gap between 8 actual points and 12.8 expected points is not a rounding error. It is the difference between 18th place and a plausible mid-table existence. For context, here is how Sunderland's xPoints delta compares within the bottom five:

ClubActual PointsxPointsDelta
Sunderland812.8-4.8
League bottom-5 avg~9~11~-2.0

No team in the division is bleeding more points to variance. At 12.8 expected points, Sunderland would still be in the bottom half, but they would be breathing. At 8, they are drowning.

Finishing: Slightly Cold, Not Frozen

Sunderland have scored 8 goals against an expected total of 8.86, a finishing delta of -0.86. That is mildly unlucky but unremarkable. They are generating 12.2 shots per match, slightly below the 13.5 they concede, and their cumulative xG of 8.86 from 122 shots suggests the quality of those chances has been modest. This is not a side creating gilt-edged opportunities and fluffing them. This is a side creating mediocre opportunities and converting them at a mediocre rate.

The finishing is not where the curse lives.

Defense: Where the Bleeding Won't Stop

Here is where the numbers turn genuinely grim. Sunderland have conceded 17 goals from an xGA of 10.42. That is a defensive variance of +6.58 goals, meaning opponents have scored roughly 63% more than the quality of their chances warranted. Some of that is goalkeeping. Some is defensive errors on set pieces. Some is sheer, brainless misfortune, the kind of deflection or long-range strike that no tactical setup prevents.

Six and a half goals of defensive overperformance by the opposition, in ten matches, is extraordinary. It is the engine of the entire curse.

Schedule and Injuries: The Dog That Didn't Bite

Sunderland's schedule strength sits at 1.28, meaning their fixture list has been roughly 28% harder than average. That partly explains the negative net xG of -1.56. They have been outshot 135 to 122 and out-chanced on expected goals. A tougher-than-average slate will do that.

What has not hurt them is injuries. Their injury burden of 65 is well below the league average of approximately 120. This is a fully fit squad producing these results. That fact cuts both ways: it means regression could arrive without needing reinforcements, but it also means there is no cavalry coming off the treatment table to change the equation.

What Regression Would Actually Buy Them

If Sunderland's defensive variance reverts even halfway to the mean over the next ten matches, that alone would save them roughly three goals. Combined with a normalizing schedule, their xPoints model projects something closer to 1.3 points per match, which would put them on pace for approximately 38-40 points across a full season. That is survival. Barely.

But regression is a tendency, not a guarantee. Sunderland's underlying process, a negative net xG of -1.56 through ten games, confirms this is a squad that gets outplayed on balance. The curse is real. So is the mediocrity underneath it. Fixing one without fixing the other still leaves them staring at the dotted line.

Premier League · CLS evolution
Sunderland — season trajectory
How Sunderland's composite luck score has evolved matchweek by matchweek.
Current
-37
Cursed (< -40) Neutral Blessed (> +40)
11 data points · Source: CURSD
Free

Liked this? Get more.

Weekly analysis like this one, in your inbox every Monday. 5 picks the CURSD way: cursed teams ripe for regression, blessed teams due to cool off.

No spam. One email per week. Unsubscribe anytime.

Share

Common Questions

Sunderland Are the Unluckiest Team in the Premier League. The Numbers Are Brutal?

A 4.8-point gap between expected and actual points makes Sunderland the most cursed side in England.

Which team is the most cursed in Premier League?

Sunderland currently has the lowest CURSD Luck Score in Premier League: A 4.8-point gap between expected and actual points makes Sunderland the most cursed side in England.

Read next