Blog/⚽ Premier League

The Premier League's Defensive Luck Rankings: Who's Cursed, Who's Blessed

Coventry have conceded nearly double their expected goals against. Everton, improbably, are on the right side of fortune.

Bottom line: Coventry's defense is conceding at nearly twice the rate expected, making them the unluckiest team in the Premier League by defensive variance.

Through November 18, 2026, every Premier League side has played enough matches for the gap between goals conceded and expected goals against (xGA) to start telling us something real. This signal, sometimes called the defensive luck gap, measures how many more (or fewer) goals a team has conceded relative to what the quality of chances they've faced would predict. According to FBref data, a large positive gap, where actual goals conceded far exceed xGA, typically reflects some blend of poor goalkeeping, defensive mistakes on the margins, and plain old misfortune. Historically, these gaps regress. The question is always how far and how fast.

Most Cursed by Defensive Luck

RankTeamGoals ConcededxGAGap
1Coventry199.3+9.7
2Crystal Palace2416.0+8.0
3Sunderland1710.4+6.6
4Manchester City136.7+6.3
5Bournemouth148.6+5.4

1. Coventry sit at 19 goals conceded against an xGA of just 9.3, a gap of +9.7 that is, to put it gently, unsustainable. If you're searching for the unluckiest team in the Premier League right now, start here. Their underlying defensive structure simply does not match the scoreline. 2. Crystal Palace have conceded 24 goals against 16.0 xGA. That's a lot of goals by any measure, but eight of them have arrived without an expected invitation. 3. Sunderland at 17 conceded versus 10.4 xGA (+6.6) are running into every ricochet and deflection the football gods can conjure. 4. Manchester City conceding 13 against 6.7 xGA is the kind of stat that makes you read it twice. City's defensive process has been elite. The results have not followed. 5. Bournemouth round out the top five at 14 conceded versus 8.6 xGA. A +5.4 gap is significant enough to be worth monitoring for anyone eyeing their fixtures.

Coventry's gap is nearly double their xGA. That doesn't happen to teams with broken defensive structures. That happens to teams the universe has selected for punishment.

Most Blessed by Defensive Luck

RankTeamGoals ConcededxGAGap
1Everton1012.1-2.1
2Brighton78.1-1.1
3Liverpool1011.0-1.0
4Leeds89.0-1.0
5Arsenal54.6-0.4

1. Everton have conceded 10 against 12.1 xGA, a -2.1 gap that represents the best defensive fortune in the league. Enjoy it while it's yours, Toffees. 2. Brighton at 7 conceded versus 8.1 xGA (-1.1) are quietly benefiting from opponents finishing below expectation. 3. Liverpool conceding 10 against 11.0 xGA is a modest -1.0, the kind of number that could reflect genuine goalkeeping quality as much as luck. 4. Leeds at 8 conceded versus 9.0 xGA sit right alongside Liverpool in the mild-blessing range. 5. Arsenal conceding just 5 against 4.6 xGA (-0.4) are barely on this list. Their defense is simply that good, and the luck component is negligible.

What This Tells Us

The range from Coventry's +9.7 to Everton's -2.1 spans nearly 12 goals of variance on a single signal. That is enormous. Historical Premier League data shows that defensive luck gaps tend to halve over the second half of a season, meaning Coventry should expect some relief and Everton should brace for a correction. Neither outcome is guaranteed on any timetable, but the math is patient, and the math almost always wins.

Premier League Β· Signal ranking
Defensive variance
Every team ranked from most cursed (top, red) to most blessed (bottom, green) by this single isolated signal.
1
Coventry
-9.70
2
Crystal Palace
-8.02
3
Sunderland
-6.58
4
Manchester City
-6.27
5
Bournemouth
-5.40
6
Chelsea
-4.58
7
Nottingham Forest
-4.43
8
Manchester United
-3.95
9
Ipswich
-3.94
10
Newcastle
-3.83
11
Fulham
-2.70
12
Aston Villa
-2.11
13
Tottenham
-1.93
14
Brentford
-0.55
15
Hull City
-0.40
16
Arsenal
-0.36
17
Leeds
+0.96
18
Liverpool
+0.96
19
Brighton
+1.05
20
Everton
+2.14
Cursed (below league average) Blessed
Source: CURSD CLS
Free

Liked this? Get more.

Weekly analysis like this one, in your inbox every Monday. 5 picks the CURSD way: cursed teams ripe for regression, blessed teams due to cool off.

No spam. One email per week. Unsubscribe anytime.

Share

Common Questions

The Premier League's Defensive Luck Rankings: Who's Cursed, Who's Blessed?

Coventry have conceded nearly double their expected goals against. Everton, improbably, are on the right side of fortune.

Which team is the most cursed in Premier League?

Coventry currently has the lowest CURSD Luck Score in Premier League: Coventry have conceded nearly double their expected goals against. Everton, improbably, are on the right side of fortune.

Which team is the most blessed in Premier League?

Everton currently has the highest CURSD Luck Score in Premier League.

Read next