Bottom line: Five football clubs across Europe's top five leagues are losing at rates their underlying numbers simply do not support.
As of November 16, 2026, Le Havre, Sunderland, Borussia Mönchengladbach, Valencia, and Monza occupy a strange and specific category. They are all, by any standard metric, struggling badly. But the numbers beneath the surface, the expected-goals models and points projections tracked by CURSD's Luck Index and corroborated by data from FBref and Understat, tell a different story. Each of these five sides has been punished by finishing variance, narrow-margin results, or both. None of them deserve the records they carry.
Here is where they stand:
| Rank | Team | League | Pts | xPts | Luck Index |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Le Havre | Ligue 1 | 2 | 12.0 | -45 |
| 2 | Sunderland | Premier League | 8 | 12.8 | -37 |
| 3 | B. Mönchengladbach | Bundesliga | 4 | 9.8 | -37 |
| 4 | Valencia | La Liga | 9 | 12.8 | -33 |
| 5 | Monza | Serie A | 7 | 16.2 | -28 |
1. Le Havre - Ligue 1
Ten matches. Zero wins. Two points from a possible 12.0 expected points. That 10-point gap is the largest in any of Europe's top five leagues right now, and it earns Le Havre a luckscore of -45, the worst on the planet.
The underlying process has not been good, exactly, but it has been adequate for survival. A team generating 12.0 xPoints through ten matches is a team that should be sitting mid-table, not rooted to the bottom with a 0-2-8 record. Regression to the mean would put them on roughly 15 points across a full season's worth of remaining fixtures at this rate, which would be unremarkable. Instead they are historically dire.
Le Havre have conceded goals on sequences where their opponents' expected-goal values were vanishingly small. The kind of finishes that go in one time out of eight have been going in one time out of three.
2. Sunderland - Premier League
The unluckiest team in the Premier League is Sunderland, whose 8 points from 12.8 xPoints represents a shortfall that has them four or five places lower in the table than their performances merit.
Sunderland's close-game record tells the story cleanly. Per FBref data, their goal difference in matches decided by one goal is atrocious relative to the chances created and conceded. They are losing the tight ones, repeatedly, in ways that the shot maps do not predict. A 2-2-6 record looks like a team being outclassed. The underlying data looks like a team being unlucky.
Four points is the difference between relegation anxiety and comfortable anonymity. Sunderland are owed those four points. Whether they ever collect is another matter.
3. Borussia Mönchengladbach - Bundesliga
Gladbach's 4 points from 9.8 xPoints is a 59% shortfall, the steepest percentage gap on this list. Their 1-1-7 record through nine matches includes at least four defeats in which they held an xG advantage on the day.
That is a team losing matches it is winning on the pitch. It tends not to last.
4. Valencia - La Liga
Valencia's 9 points from 12 matches and 12.8 xPoints place them in a tier of underperformance that is painful but not catastrophic, a gap of roughly one win's worth of points. The Luck Index of -33 reflects that steady, grinding erosion rather than any single collapse.
Their three draws are the quiet engine of this misfortune. Per Understat, Valencia have drawn multiple matches in which their xG totals suggested victories, turning two-point swings into zero-point swings over and over.
5. Monza - Serie A
Monza's case might be the most remarkable on this list, not for the Luck Index itself (-28, the mildest here) but for the raw gap between actual and expected points. Seven points from 16.2 xPoints is a 9.2-point deficit, meaning Monza's season record is roughly half of what their performances have warranted.
A team collecting 16.2 xPoints through 11 Serie A matches is a mid-table side. A team with 7 points and a 2-1-8 record is a side in serious danger. Monza are both, simultaneously.
The Common Thread
Finishing variance is the shared affliction. All five teams are conceding goals at rates above their expected goals against while converting their own chances at rates below expectation. They are, collectively, on the wrong side of the most volatile variable in football, and they are there in bunches. The numbers say correction is coming. The table, for now, does not care.



